The role of a tank in Mythic+ has been significantly reshaped in the War Within Patch 11.2. Dungeon-wide adjustments that increased enemy health while lowering their damage have fundamentally altered the balance of power. This shift has placed a greater emphasis on a tank’s personal damage contribution as a critical factor for success, turning them from pure survivalists into key offensive contributors for any raid or dungeon group. While the tank meta is still evolving with class tuning and new tier set acquisition, a clear hierarchy is emerging as of this date.
This tier list for mythic content in Patch 11.2 breaks down the strongest specializations, focusing on optimization for mid-to-high-level keys where the distinctions between tanks become most pronounced.
What’s inside this guide:
- Tier Overview – S through D rankings for all Tank specializations in this tier list for mythic play.
- Meta Context – Key balance changes and influential factors this season, impacting both DPS and tanks.
- Spec Highlights – In-depth analysis of each tank spec’s strengths and weaknesses.
- Seasonal Updates – How the meta shifts with each patch and tuning update.
You might want to check out the following guides from us as well:
How This Tier List is Ranked
The following criteria are weighed to determine the final placements for each tank in this tier list for mythic difficulty. The current meta has shifted the importance of these pillars, rewarding tanks who offer a more complete package for both dungeon and raid encounters.
- Survivability & Damage Mitigation (Most Important): A dead tank means a dead key. This remains the absolute foundation of the role. This criterion evaluates a tank’s fundamental ability to stay alive, ranking the most durable tanks based on their consistent mitigation, reliable self-healing, and powerful defensive cooldowns that can be mapped across an entire dungeon.
- Damage Contribution: More important than ever, this is the primary differentiator between a good and great tank spec this season. With higher enemy health pools, a tank’s personal DPS output—both sustained AoE and single-target burst—is crucial for meeting unforgiving timers. High tank DPS can make or break a key.
- Party Utility & Control: A tank’s ability to enable their group and control the flow of combat. This ranges from offensive buffs/debuffs that amplify party DPS, to critical mob control (stuns, grips, silences), and a steady stream of interrupts. Effective mob control is essential in the current dungeon pool.
- Mobility: The effectiveness with which a tank can navigate encounters, kite when necessary, and control the pacing of a dungeon. High mobility allows for more aggressive pulls, safer resets, and faster transitions between packs, a valuable trait for any mythic tier.
- High-Key Representation: We analyze data from live servers as of this date to see which specs are successfully clearing the highest keys. This provides a real-world check on their synergy, scaling, and overall playability in the most demanding mythic tier of content, offering insights separate from raid performance.
TL;DR Summary: The S-Tier includes Protection Warrior, Vengeance Demon Hunter, and Brewmaster Monk—the most dominant and well-rounded specializations for pushing high-end content. Their performance in this top mythic tier is unmatched on this date.
| Tank Spec | Tier | Key Strengths | Main Weaknesses | Group Buff / Utility |
| Protection Warrior | S-Tier | Extremely durable, high burst damage with Mountain Thane, strong mob control | Buff favors physical comps only, less synergy with caster-heavy groups | Battle Shout (Attack Power), Rallying Cry, AoE silence/stun |
| Vengeance Demon Hunter | S-Tier | Excellent survivability, top mobility, strong AoE control, caster synergy | Slightly lower personal DPS than Warrior/Monk in bursts | Chaos Brand (3% magic dmg), AoE silence/fear/grip |
| Brewmaster Monk | S-Tier | Highest single-target/priority DPS, Stagger smooths damage, solid threat | Relies on healer support, limited group defensives | Mystic Touch (8% physical dmg), Leg Sweep, Ring of Peace |
| Protection Paladin | A-Tier | Best utility kit (Blessings, Devotion Aura, Lay on Hands, Battle Rez), strong interrupts | Fragile outside cooldowns, mid-range DPS, vulnerable gaps | Devotion Aura (3% dmg reduction), multiple Blessings, Battle Rez |
| Guardian Druid | B-Tier | High health pool, consistent mitigation, Stampeding Roar, Battle Rez | Lowest DPS among tanks, utility overlaps with Resto Druid | Mark of the Wild (3% versatility), Roar, Vortex, Battle Rez |
| Blood Death Knight | C-Tier | Unique grips (Death Grip, Gorefiend’s), strong self-healing, AMS for magic | Lowest tank DPS, inconsistent durability, lost Abomination Limb, AMZ nerfed | Death Grip utility, Gorefiend’s Grasp, Anti Magic Shell (self only) |
S-Tier Tank Rankings – The Meta Frontrunners
Specializations in this mythic tier represent the pinnacle of performance in Warcraft. They offer a potent combination of damage, survivability, and utility, with the ultimate choice often depending on the group’s DPS composition.
Protection Warrior
Ascending to the top tier, the Protection Warrior has become a powerhouse of both damage and durability thanks to a significant change in its hero talents and a powerful new tier set.
- Strengths: The Mountain Thane hero specialization is the primary driver of its offensive power, providing exceptional burst damage and achieving top tier damage in all scenarios. Defensively, it is incredibly robust, featuring high self-healing, a very short cooldown on Shield Wall, and multiple sources of damage reduction, making it one of the most durable tanks. Top-tier utility includes a valuable AoE silence and a multi-purpose AoE stun for excellent mob control.
- Weaknesses: Its primary group buff, Battle Shout, provides Attack Power. This makes it difficult to optimize in a meta that generally favors caster DPS, but it’s a huge boon for comps with specs like a Beast Mastery Hunter.
- Season 3 Outlook: The Protection Warrior is the premier high-damage, high-survivability option. It is the definitive choice for enabling physical damage and melee-centric groups that might include a Beast Mastery Hunter or rogue, defining its own corner of the tank meta.
Vengeance Demon Hunter
The Vengeance Demon Hunter remains the most popular and arguably most well-rounded tank, continuing a long-standing pattern of meta dominance due to its near-perfect toolkit for Mythic+.
- Strengths: Its greatest asset is the Chaos Brand debuff (now 3% magic damage in The War Within), making it the default choice for powerful caster compositions. It is exceptionally sturdy and highly mobile, with excellent utility including an AoE silence and crowd control sigils. A high degree of self-sufficiency lessens the burden on the healer.
- Weaknesses: While its personal DPS is highly competitive and contributes enormous AoE, it can be slightly edged out by the burst windows of an optimized Warrior or Monk. Its self-sustain model can be challenged by significant healing reduction effects.
- Meta Standing: The Vengeance Demon Hunter is the premier tank for caster-heavy compositions. It offers a complete package that enables a fast-paced, high-control playstyle, defining the highest mythic tier of play for many groups.
Brewmaster Monk
Emerging as a high-damage challenger, the Brewmaster Monk is a dominant force capable of exceptional offensive output thanks to recent buffs.
- Strengths: The Brewmaster has become a damage powerhouse, particularly with the Shado-Pan hero specialization. Its single-target and priority damage can exceed that of all other tanks, providing a huge boost to group DPS. The Mystic Touch debuff (buffed to 8% physical damage) is a massive gain for the right comp. Defensively, it is more resilient than in previous seasons and is one of the easiest tanks for holding AoE threat.
- Weaknesses: Offers less group utility compared to its S-Tier counterparts and relies more heavily on external healing. The Mystic Touch debuff is also less valuable in a caster-centric meta than it is in a raid setting with more physical DPS. The potential for its high damage to be tuned down looms as a risk.
- Current Performance: The Brewmaster is the alternative high-damage engine for melee compositions, trading some utility and self-sufficiency for potentially even greater personal DPS.
A-Tier Tank Rankings – The Powerful Contender
This specialization possesses a unique niche that can elevate it to the S-Tier in the right circumstances, though it lacks the all-around consistency of the top frontrunners in this tier list for mythic content.
Protection Paladin
The utility of a Protection Paladin is legendary and remains its core strength, allowing it to solve problems that no other tank can.
- Strengths: Unmatched ability to control caster packs with a plethora of interrupts from Avenger’s Shield. The utility kit is robust, offering powerful group support cooldowns, a crucial battle resurrection (Intercession), personal immunities, and a notable damage increase from its tier set which helps its overall DPS contribution.
- Weaknesses: Its primary vulnerability is survivability. The specialization can feel fragile outside of its major defensive cooldowns, leaving it with dangerous moments of vulnerability. This, combined with relatively low priority damage, holds it back from the highest mythic tier.
- Season 3 Outlook: A high-skill, high-reward tank that excels in caster-heavy dungeons or with less coordinated groups that benefit from its exceptional interrupt control. A strong choice for this mythic tier.
B-Tier Tank Rankings – The Niche Option
This tank is viable and can perform well but is held back by certain design elements or meta factors that place it a step behind the more competitive options in this tier list for mythic play.
Guardian Druid
The Guardian Druid’s greatest advantage is its accessibility and straightforward playstyle, but it faces significant challenges in a high-key environment without a significant rework.
- Strengths: The Elune’s Chosen hero tree provides solid defensive value, and its simple rotation allows for high consistency. It brings good group utility with Stampeding Roar, Ursol’s Vortex, and a battle resurrection, making it one of the more durable tanks in terms of raw health.
- Weaknesses: DPS output is among the lowest of all tanks, a major liability when timers are tight. Its defensive model, which relies on a massive health pool and steady self-healing, is particularly vulnerable to heal reduction mechanics, making its large health pool a liability to top off under pressure. Critically, much of its utility is also brought by the highly popular Restoration Druid, creating redundancy that hurts its standing in high-level DPS rankings.
- Meta Standing: A solid but unexceptional tank whose core strengths are often overshadowed. Its low DPS and potential utility overlap make it a less common sight in high-end groups this date.
C-Tier Tank Rankings – The Challenged Specialization
This specialization currently faces fundamental challenges with its damage, survivability, or utility that place it at a considerable disadvantage in this tier list for mythic challenges.
Blood Death Knight
The Blood Death Knight continues to struggle with its core design in the context of modern Mythic+, even when compared to its often stellar raid performance.
- Strengths: Offers the unique and powerful utility of Death Grip and Gorefiend’s Grasp for controlling mob positioning. Anti-Magic Shell remains a potent personal defensive for specific encounters.
- Weaknesses: DPS output is low, and its survivability is precarious and binary—feeling sturdy one moment and highly susceptible to one-shots the next. It struggles to be one of the consistently durable tanks. The loss of key utility like Abomination Limb and the significant nerf to their group utility cooldown, Anti-Magic Zone, further diminish its value compared to other tanks.
- Current Performance: The Blood Death Knight is in a difficult position. Its unique utility is not enough to compensate for its low DPS and inconsistent survivability, making it the least represented tank in the meta as of this date.
D-Tier – Not Recommended for The War Within Season 3
Currently, no specialization is in the D Tier. A spec would land here if its damage or survivability was so low it couldn’t meet basic checks, or if it had a critical design flaw making it a liability. Fortunately, the current tank balance in Warcraft ensures all tank specializations are viable for completing a vast range of content outside of the most competitive mythic tier of play.
Seasonal Updates
August 20, 2025: Initial tier list for mythic published for War Within patch 11.2. The meta is defined by the high damage output of Warrior and Monk, challenging the utility-driven dominance of the Vengeance Demon Hunter. The current tank balance is healthy, with multiple specs viable at the highest level. We will update this guide on a future date following any significant change or tuning.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best Mythic+ tanks in WoW The War Within patch 11.2?
In Season 3 of The War Within, the strongest tanks are Protection Warrior, Vengeance Demon Hunter, and Brewmaster Monk. These specializations stand out because they combine high personal DPS with reliable damage mitigation and valuable group buffs. Prot Warrior dominates melee comps with Battle Shout and burst damage, Vengeance DH supports caster-heavy groups through Chaos Brand, and Brewmaster Monk offers unmatched priority DPS and Mystic Touch for physical classes. Together, they define the current S-tier of Mythic+ tank rankings.
Why is Protection Warrior ranked so high in Mythic+ for 11.2?
Prot Warrior surged ahead this season due to the Mountain Thane hero talents and its new tier set bonuses, both of which drastically boosted damage and self-sustain. With short cooldowns like Shield Wall, access to AoE silence through Disruptive Shout, and a layered mitigation system (Shield Block, Ignore Pain, Last Stand), Prot Warrior excels at smoothing incoming damage while pumping competitive DPS. Its synergy with melee-heavy teams makes it a staple in high keys.
How strong is Vengeance Demon Hunter in Season 3 Mythic+?
Vengeance DH remains a top-tier tank in 11.2 thanks to its toolkit flexibility and group synergy. Its self-sustain model allows it to heal much of its own damage taken, reducing healer stress. Add in mobility from Infernal Strikes, AoE control from sigils, and the Chaos Brand debuff which boosts all magic damage by 3%, and DH becomes the best choice for caster-heavy comps. While its personal damage may lag slightly behind Warriors and Monks in burst windows, its balance of survivability, mobility, and utility keeps it firmly in S-tier.
Why is Brewmaster Monk in the S-tier for Mythic+ tanks in 11.2?
Brewmaster’s kit was heavily buffed, especially with the Shado-Pan hero specialization, which gave it massive single-target and priority damage. The Mystic Touch debuff now increases physical damage taken by enemies by 8%, making it highly desirable in groups with melee DPS. Brew’s Stagger mechanic smooths dangerous spikes into manageable ticks, which makes incoming damage predictable for healers. Despite leaning more on external healing, Brewmaster’s contribution to group DPS and overall dungeon pace makes it one of the best tanks this patch.
Is Protection Paladin still good in The War Within 11.2 Mythic+?
Yes, Prot Paladin remains a powerful A-tier tank. Its utility toolkit is unmatched: Avenger’s Shield offers frequent ranged interrupts, Devotion Aura gives passive damage reduction to the party, and Blessings provide immunities, freedoms, or damage redirection. Prot Paladins can also cast Lay on Hands for emergency healing and bring a combat resurrection. However, their personal survivability outside of major cooldowns is weaker compared to the S-tier tanks, and their damage output is mid-range. This combination places them just below the top performers.
Why is Guardian Druid considered a weaker Mythic+ tank in 11.2?
Guardian Druids are durable thanks to large health pools and defensive talents like Ironfur, but they underperform in Mythic+ because of low DPS and redundant utility. Many of their unique tools, such as Stampeding Roar or Battle Resurrection, are already brought by Restoration Druids, one of the most common healers. This overlap makes them less attractive for high-key groups. Coupled with weak damage compared to other tanks and vulnerability to healing reduction effects, Guardian sits firmly in B-tier for this season.
What happened to Blood Death Knight in 11.2 Mythic+?
Blood DK fell behind in Season 3 due to several factors. Abomination Limb, their iconic mass-grip ability from previous expansions, was removed, stripping away a unique form of utility. Their Anti Magic Zone was heavily nerfed to a 4-minute cooldown, making it less valuable in dungeons. At the same time, their personal DPS output lags far behind other tanks, and their survivability is inconsistent, swinging between unkillable and dangerously fragile. As a result, Blood DK has the lowest high-key representation of all tank specs.
Did the Anti Magic Zone nerf affect Blood DK’s place in the tier list?
Absolutely. Anti Magic Zone was once a signature utility for group-wide magic mitigation. With its cooldown extended and duration shortened, it lost much of its value in dungeons, where frequent, smaller magic hits are common. This nerf left Blood DK with unique pulls via Death Grip and Gorefiend’s Grasp, but without the group-saving cooldowns that other tanks bring. Combined with weak DPS, this change solidified Blood DK’s drop to the bottom tier for Mythic+.
How does Chaos Brand impact tank rankings in Mythic+?
Chaos Brand is one of the strongest group buffs a tank can provide. By increasing all magic damage taken by enemies by 3%, it amplifies the output of classes like Mages, Warlocks, Balance Druids, and Shadow Priests. In a meta where composition balance matters, this debuff ensures Vengeance Demon Hunter fits naturally into caster-heavy groups. Its passive nature means no extra actions are needed, making it a constant damage increase for the party.
Why is Abomination Limb mentioned when ranking tanks in 11.2?
Abomination Limb was a key ability from Shadowlands that allowed Blood DKs to grip and cluster multiple enemies every two minutes, creating unmatched control in Mythic+. Its removal in War Within stripped Blood DK of its defining utility. Without it, the spec has fewer tools to control large pulls compared to Warrior or Monk, leaving it disadvantaged in modern dungeons where control and pace are crucial.
What criteria determine Mythic+ tank rankings in WoW?
Tank rankings are determined by five main factors: survivability, personal DPS, utility, mobility, and representation in high keys. Survivability and mitigation are non-negotiable, while personal DPS has become more important than ever in Season 3. Utility (buffs, interrupts, CC), mobility for kiting, and proven performance in live high keys round out the criteria used for tier placement.
Why is tank damage important in Mythic+?
Tank damage is vital because dungeon mobs in The War Within have higher health pools, and key timers are unforgiving. Tanks who contribute strong AoE and single-target damage help groups beat timers and reduce healer strain by ending fights faster. In high keys, even a 10–15% damage difference between tanks can mean the difference between timing or failing a run.
Which tank has the best survivability in Mythic+?
Protection Warrior currently leads in survivability due to layered mitigation tools like Shield Block, Ignore Pain, Last Stand, and Shield Wall. Vengeance Demon Hunter and Guardian Druid also offer sturdy defensive kits, but Blood DK’s survivability is less consistent and relies heavily on Death Strike healing windows. Paladin can survive through cooldown chaining but is fragile when those tools are down.
Which tank has the best group utility?
Protection Paladin offers unmatched utility with interrupts, immunities, external healing, Devotion Aura, and a combat resurrection. Warriors provide Battle Shout and Rallying Cry, Monks bring Mystic Touch, and DHs bring Chaos Brand. Guardian Druids contribute Stampeding Roar, Mark of the Wild, and a battle resurrection, but much of that overlaps with healer Druids. Blood DK’s main utility is mob control via Death Grip, which is powerful but situational.
Which tank is best for melee-heavy groups?
Melee-heavy groups benefit most from Brewmaster Monk and Protection Warrior. Brewmaster’s Mystic Touch debuff increases all physical damage dealt to enemies by 8%, while Warrior’s Battle Shout boosts Attack Power. Together, these buffs amplify Rogues, Warriors, Hunters, and other physical DPS, making these tanks ideal for physical-heavy party compositions.
Which tank is best for caster-heavy groups?
Vengeance Demon Hunter is the premier tank for caster compositions. Its Chaos Brand debuff increases all magic damage dealt to enemies, giving Mages, Warlocks, and Balance Druids a free DPS boost. Paired with the DH’s own mobility, sigils, and tanky self-healing, it creates one of the smoothest experiences for caster-heavy keys.
Do all tanks bring a raid buff in 11.2?
Almost all tanks bring a raid or party buff in 11.2: Prot Warrior offers Battle Shout, Vengeance DH brings Chaos Brand, Brewmaster Monk grants Mystic Touch, Guardian Druid provides Mark of the Wild, and Prot Paladin contributes Devotion Aura. Blood DK is the only exception, as it no longer has Abomination Limb or a party buff, putting it at a disadvantage in group utility.
How important is mobility for Mythic+ tanks?
Mobility is crucial in Mythic+ because tanks often need to kite when incoming damage becomes unmanageable or reposition mobs quickly for interrupts and line-of-sight pulls. Vengeance DH and Brewmaster Monk are the most mobile tanks, allowing fast resets and smoother dungeon pacing. In contrast, Blood DK is the least mobile, relying on grips and slows rather than movement abilities.
Can lower-tier tanks still complete high Mythic+ keys?
Yes. While tier lists highlight efficiency at the very top of play, all tanks are viable for high-level content in Season 3. A Guardian Druid or Blood DK in the hands of a skilled player can still time +20 keys. The differences become noticeable at the very cutting edge, where every percentage of damage, uptime, and control matters.
How often do Mythic+ tank rankings change in WoW?
Tank rankings can change mid-season due to Blizzard’s class tuning or hotfixes. For example, buffs to Prot Warrior in 11.2 elevated it from mid-tier to S-tier, while nerfs to Blood DK utility pushed it down. Tier sets and dungeon design also influence rankings. On average, expect rankings to shift with each patch or mid-season tuning pass.
